Cartographic Projection
every map is wrong, and by exactly how much
Concept

Line scale factor — where it appears

The scale factor appropriate to a whole line rather than to a point, obtained by integrating the point scale along it. A survey needs it rather than the point value, and using the value at one end of a long line is an error that grows with the line's length.

Named by 7 essays across 3 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

A scale factor is a property of a point, and a distance is not. The grid scale factor sampled along a 362 km line on the British National Grid at a bearing of 90°, with the three rules in use drawn as the constants they replace it by. In a transverse Mercator k depends on the easting almost alone and goes as its square, so along an east–west line the curve is very nearly a parabola. The endpoint mean is the chord across it and lands 268.6 ppm high, which is 97.3 m over this line. Simpson's rule integrates a parabola exactly and lands 0.004 ppm out — 1.3 mm. Neither number is about the line's length.

The scale factor of a line

A scale factor is a property of a point and a distance is not measured at a point. The three rules in use for averaging one along a line differ by a hundred metres on a 362-kilometre baseline, and which of them is adequate is decided by the line's direction rather than its length.

practice · Grid The scale along the Madrid–Tokyo corridor. The scale factor of four projections along the great circle from Madrid to Tokyo, each normalised to its own average over the route so the comparison is of variation rather than of size. The oblique Mercator whose own equator is laid along the corridor holds the scale to 0 parts per million; Mercator varies by 118.7% over the same line. A corridor is a curve, not a region, and the projection an area criterion picks is not the one a curve wants.

Choosing for a line, not a region

Every criterion in this subject integrates over an area. A pipeline, a railway or a coastal survey is a curve, and the projection an area criterion picks for it is not the one it should have — measurably, by a factor of five thousand.

choosing · Choosing A grid scaled to the ground, and where it stops being one. A surface coordinate system on the British National Grid: the grid multiplied by 1.0004044, the reciprocal of the combined factor at a project origin 120 m above the ellipsoid, so that a grid distance equals a ground distance there. It is exact at the origin by construction and wrong everywhere else, and the two directions are not comparable — the axis is logarithmic across five decades. 60 km due east the set-out distance is out by 5559 mm, and the same distance due north by 20.5 mm. The scale factor of a transverse Mercator depends on the easting and almost not at all on the northing, so a system sold as good "within a few kilometres" has a useful area that is a strip rather than a circle.

A grid scaled to the ground is not a map

Construction sites work in coordinates where a tape reading equals a computed distance, which is achieved by multiplying the national grid by a constant. The result is exact at one point, degrades east–west forty times faster than north–south, and is not a map projection at all.

practice · Grid Four steps between a tape and a drawing. A slope distance of 76.895 km measured at 3.2° on ground 220 m above sea level, reduced to the British National Grid, with every step drawn on a logarithmic scale in millimetres. The slope reduction is the largest by a wide margin at 119.90 m and is the one everybody applies. The grid reduction is 30.23 m. The fourth bar is not a step at all: it is what using the levelled height where the height above the ellipsoid is wanted costs, with a geoid separation of 48.5 m — 583 mm, which is 1.9% of the grid reduction it sits beside and 29 times the tolerance the job closes to. Reading a correction's importance off its share of the chain is how it gets dropped.

What a tape measures

Four steps stand between an instrument reading and a coordinate, and their sizes are not in the order anybody expects. On a 77-kilometre line the slope reduction is 120 metres, the grid reduction 30, and a step nobody names — using the height above sea level where the height above the ellipsoid is wanted — is 583 millimetres.

practice · Reduction The two reductions, at a grid factor of 1.0004. A measurement made on the ground has to be brought to the ellipsoid and then to the grid, and the two corrections have opposite signs. The elevation factor is R/(R+h) and always shrinks; the grid factor here is 1.0004, which stretches. Their product is the only number a surveyor can use. They cancel exactly at 2551 metres. At 1500 metres the combined factor is 165 parts per million, which is 1.65 metres on a 10 kilometre baseline.

The ground is not the grid

A tape measure on a hillside has to be brought down to the ellipsoid and then out onto the map, and the two corrections have opposite signs. On a grid whose scale factor exceeds one there is exactly one elevation where they cancel — 2,551 metres, for a factor of 1.0004.

datums · Height A 1-hectare parcel across British National Grid, at 52°N. The departure of a plan's dimensions from the ground's, across the width of the zone, as a length and as an area. The area curve is the length curve doubled — an areal scale factor is the square of a linear one, and squaring a small departure doubles it — so a parcel whose sides are each 399 parts per million short on the central meridian is 797 short in area. On a 1-hectare parcel that is 8.0 square metres at the central meridian and 8.0 at 0.00° out.

An area on the grid is not an area on the ground

A grid's scale factor is a property of lengths and what a surveyor sells is an area. Squaring a departure doubles it, so a hectare drawn on the British grid at its central meridian has 10,008 square metres of ground under it — and correcting an area with the line factor instead of its square leaves half the error behind.

practice · Grid The widest zone a tolerance of 690 parts per million allows. At each latitude, the half-width at which a transverse Mercator grid with its scale factor rebalanced for that width reaches 690 ppm at its worst point. That tolerance is the one UTM actually meets at the equator, so the curve passes through UTM's own 3° there — and rises to 37.0° at 85° north, because a degree of longitude covers cos φ of the ground and the scale error goes as the square of the ground width. Six degrees is the answer at one latitude.

Sixty zones was a decision about one latitude

Twelve rungs price a grid, a zone, an origin and a reference, and every one of them works inside a single zone. The number of zones has never been asked about: six degrees meets its tolerance at the equator and is loose everywhere else, so a system spending the same tolerance evenly would use 51 zones at the equator and 8 at 82° — and UTM's worst error is 981 parts per million, not the 400 always quoted.

practice · Grid

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Scale factorNational GridToleranceCombined factorZoneEllipsoidal heightPurposeTransverse MercatorVerificationCentral meridianConventionGeoid

All concepts