Cartographic Projection
every map is wrong, and by exactly how much
Concept

Hessian — where it appears

The matrix of second derivatives of an objective, which near a minimum carries the whole local shape. Its eigenvalues are the reciprocal squares of the basin's widths, so nineteen evaluations give the shape a volume sweep would need a much finer grid to resolve.

Named by 3 essays across 3 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Where a ridge, a valley and the pass between them curves the other way. The Gaussian curvature of a stated terrain over a 80-kilometre window, with the sign shown by the colour and the size by the ink. Positive on the summits and in the hollows, negative everywhere between — which is most of it: 79 per cent of the curved area. The extremes are 2.2e+4 times the Earth's own curvature, which is the quantity every argument on a sphere takes to be the curvature of the thing being mapped.

Where the surface curves the other way

The impossibility of a perfect map is usually argued on surfaces whose curvature is positive everywhere. The surface a map of the ground actually depicts is not one of them: a stated terrain is saddle-shaped over 79 per cent of its curved area, its curvature runs to twenty-two thousand times the Earth's own, and even a single smooth hill is concave over 89 per cent of itself.

impossibility · Curvature The basin has three widths, and they differ by a factor of 4.6. Two sections through the near-optimal basin of the Robinson aspect over Japan, drawn at one scale. Each ellipse is the set of aspects whose score is twice the optimum's, from the objective's own second derivative at the optimum: 32.1°, 16.0°, 6.9° along the three principal directions. A single number for "the width of the basin" is the cube root of their product, 15.3°, and it is not any of them.

The basins have widths as well as depths

Measuring the height of the pass left one thing owed: shape means widths too. Measured, the basin has three of them — 32°, 16° and 7° at Japan — it gets wider rather than narrower as the region grows, and the exponent it predicts overshoots the measured one by half again.

choosing · Choosing The points a projection cannot move. The critical points of a stated field, found twice: once on the sphere from its own gradient, and once in Lambert cylindrical's page coordinates from the page's own numbers, with nothing shared between the two searches. seven points, 3 maxima, 2 saddles and 2 minima, and the two sets agree in position to 2.3e-7 degrees and in type at every one. The page's Jacobian is invertible wherever the map is a map, so it sends a zero gradient to a zero gradient and cannot move a critical point anywhere.

What the page cannot move

Six rungs measure what a page does to a field's readings and every one of them moves. The critical points do not: found on the sphere and found again in a projection's own page coordinates with nothing shared between the searches, they agree to 10⁻⁷ degrees and in type at every point, on every projection. What the page does move is their shape, by a factor bounded exactly by the indicatrix's axis ratio squared.

distortion · Gradient

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

SaddleVerificationAnisotropyAspectAspect searchBasinConformalityCoordinate independenceCritical pointCurvatureDevelopableEuler characteristic

All concepts