Cartographic Projection
every map is wrong, and by exactly how much
Concept

Over determined — where it appears

A system with more conditions than unknowns, so that no exact solution generally exists. What is left over after the best fit is a residual, and the residual is a measurement of the observations rather than an embarrassment to the fit.

Named by 2 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Three distances, two degrees of freedom. The Chamberlin trimetric construction with its three centres marked. A point is placed by intersecting circles of its true distance from each centre — but three circles in a plane do not meet in a point, and the three candidate positions obtained by taking the conditions two at a time are 17.0 km apart at the sample point. They are drawn here magnified 120 times about their own centroid, which is where Chamberlin's rule puts the point. The residual is not an error in the arithmetic; it is the amount by which the sphere refuses to be a plane, and it grows as the cube of the size of the region.

Three conditions are one too many

Two distances fix a point in a plane and a third has no freedom left to be satisfied with. Chamberlin's trimetric construction averages the three positions that satisfy two conditions each, and the spread between them — never zero anywhere, 22 km over North America, growing as the cube of the region — is the price of the extra clause.

choosing · Condition Four lines of position, two unknowns, and four gaps that do not close. Four bodies at azimuths of 20°, 110°, 200°, 290° from the ship, each sight given an independent error of about 2 km along its azimuth. No point lies on all four lines. The least-squares point — the hollow dot — is the one whose squared distances to the four lines are smallest, and the dashed perpendiculars are those distances: 0.31, 2.83, 0.32, 2.83 km. The ship, the solid dot, is 3.21 km away. Three lines would have left a triangle and no residual worth the name; four leave two degrees of freedom, and the four gaps are the first quantity here that can be read as a measurement of the sights themselves.

The residual reports the error the fix was immune to

A fourth sight gives a four-line fit something three lines never had: a leftover. The leftover is a real measurement of the sights, and it is useless exactly where it is needed. One number computed from the four azimuths alone — before any star is observed — says how much of a common error reaches the residual, and it is 1 when the bodies stand at the quarters of the compass, where such an error moves the fix by nothing at all, and 0.004 when they are bunched within sixty degrees, where it moves the fix by two kilometres.

paths · Position fix

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Least-squaresResidualAzimuthCompromise projectionConditionConformalityConventionCurvatureDegrees of freedomEquidistanceEstimatorNavigation

All concepts