Cartographic Projection
every map is wrong, and by exactly how much
Concept

Network strain — where it appears

The internal distortion of an old triangulation relative to a modern frame, which no seven-parameter transformation can absorb. It is why a national grid ships an interpolated shift grid, whose spacing follows the roughness of the strain rather than any tolerance.

Named by 4 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

What 4 parts per million of network strain leaves behind. Each arrow is where the best-fitting seven-parameter transformation leaves a marker, over 36 markers laid out as a grid across OSGB36's ground. The RMS residual is 1.64 metres and the worst is 3.00 metres. Seven parameters span the constant and linear parts of a displacement field; this one is quadratic, so no choice of the seven can reach it. The arrows are drawn 27× life size.

Where a fit leaves residuals

Seven parameters can carry a rigid motion and a size exactly. A triangulation network is neither, so the best possible transformation between two datums leaves metres on the table — in a pattern, not as noise — and which seven parameters come out depends on where the markers were.

datums · Datum What grid spacing a tolerance buys. The worst bilinear interpolation error across OSGB36's ground, against the spacing of the table it is interpolated from, both axes logarithmic. The smooth shift falls by exactly four for every halving, which is what second-order interpolation does. Adding a 30 centimetre ripple 2 degrees across — three parts in a thousand of the 99 metre shift it rides on — moves the spacing needed for 20 millimetres from 1° to 0.125°, which is 64 times as many nodes.

When a formula is not enough

National mapping agencies distribute datum shifts as tables of numbers on a grid rather than as parameters. What decides the spacing that table needs is not the size of the shift — a hundred-metre shift tabulates coarsely, and a thirty-centimetre ripple riding on it does not.

datums · Datum Two parameter sets 100 metres apart, over the region they were fitted to. Each marker is drawn at a size proportional to how far the two transformations put it apart. The second set differs from the first by 100 metres of translation along the direction this network can least see, with the rotations and the scale re-fitted to absorb it — which is what a second agency's adjustment does when it chooses a different constraint. The worst disagreement anywhere in the region is 5.64 metres and the mean is 3.61. Applied at south-eastern Australia the same two sets differ by 193 metres, because the rotation that absorbed the translation here is a rotation of the whole Earth.

Two parameter sets, one transformation

Agencies publish seven-parameter datum transformations that differ by hundreds of metres in translation, and the usual reading is that one of them is better. Over the region either was fitted to they are the same transformation: a hundred metres of translation, re-absorbed by the rotations and the scale, moves a British coordinate by 5.6 metres and an Australian one by 193.

datums · Datum A chain of stations, its positions' uncertainty and its baselines'. Nine stations held at the left-hand one, with every neighbour, second neighbour and third neighbour observed. The filled ellipses are each station's own uncertainty, which grows without limit as the chain runs away from the point it is held at — 7.5 mm at the near end and 574 mm at the far. The open ellipses above each leg are the uncertainty of the baseline, drawn at the same scale: they hardly grow at all, because almost everything that is wrong with one end is wrong with the other in the same direction.

The difference of two coordinates

Three essays give a single coordinate a width. Every practical use of one is a difference of two — a distance, a bearing, a movement, an area — and the width of a difference is not the two widths combined, because the errors are not independent. Far from its datum a one-leg baseline is six times more certain than the positions it joins.

distortion · Precision

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

DatumLeast-squaresRealisationResidualToleranceVerificationDegeneracyHelmert transformationNational GridOSGB36Reference frameSimilarity transformation

All concepts