Cartographic Projection
every map is wrong, and by exactly how much
Concept

Navigation — where it appears

Getting from one place to another, which is a question about the ground and about time rather than about a map. The shortest route is a geodesic, the easiest to steer is a rhumb line, and the quickest is neither once wind and airspace are in the problem.

Named by 6 essays across one field — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

New York to Madrid on Mercator. Two routes. The great circle is 5768 km and is the shortest path on the sphere. The rhumb line holds a single compass bearing the whole way and is 5939 km — 171 km further, or 3.0 per cent. On Mercator the rhumb line departs from straight by 9.6e-16 of its own length.

Why Mercator exists

A ship can hold a compass bearing and cannot easily hold a great circle. Mercator is the answer to one question — what must a map do so that a constant bearing is a straight line — and it answers it exactly.

paths · Paths London to Tokyo, seen four ways. The same two routes on four projections. The gnomonic projection renders every great circle as an exactly straight line, which is what it is for; Mercator renders every rhumb line straight instead. Neither path changed — only the map did.

The gnomonic companion

One projection turns every great circle into a straight line, and it is the only one that does. It shows less than half the sphere, distorts enormously, and was indispensable for three centuries because of that single exact property.

paths · Paths London to Tokyo in three straight legs. The great circle, and the route a plan of three constant-heading legs actually follows between waypoints on it. The two touch at the waypoints and part between them by up to 456 km, and the flown route is 253 km longer than the direct one. The headings are 50°, 109°, 149°. Two routes. The great circle is 9559 km and is the shortest path on the sphere. The rhumb line holds a single compass bearing the whole way and is 11296 km — 1737 km further, or 18.2 per cent. On Orthographic the rhumb line departs from straight by 2.4e-1 of its own length.

Flying a curve in straight legs

Nobody steers a great circle, because a great circle requires the heading to change continuously. What is actually flown is a handful of constant-heading legs between waypoints on it, and the gap between plan and curve falls as the square of the number of legs.

paths · Paths London to Tokyo, round a 15° exclusion. The direct great circle, dashed, runs through the disc. The admissible shortest route leaves it along a great circle tangent to the rim, follows the rim, and leaves along another tangent — which is the closed-form answer and is checked against a shortest-path search over the rim that knows nothing about tangents. It costs 39 kilometres on 9559, which is 0.41 per cent. The rim stretch is 293 kilometres of it, and it is the only part of the route that is not a geodesic anywhere along its length. Drawn in Orthographic.

A route that must go round

Every route on this site so far has been free to go anywhere, and no real route is. The shortest path past a circular exclusion is two tangent great circles and an arc of the rim — a closed form that agrees with a shortest-path search to three metres in 9,598 kilometres — and it costs not the obstacle's size but the square of how far the obstacle reaches past the route.

paths · Paths What the drawn line costs, projection by projection. The ground length of the page-straight route from London to Tokyo, as a percentage above the shortest route. Two of these have names. On the gnomonic, centred on the route, the drawn line IS the shortest route, at -0.0000 per cent. On Mercator it is the rhumb, matching the rhumb's own length to 1 parts per million — which is why that projection exists. On the other eight it is a curve with no name and a cost between 0.0 and 19.6 per cent.

The line drawn straight on the page is a route

Eleven essays draw the route on the map. Nobody has drawn the map's own proposal: the ground curve somebody follows by laying a ruler on the page. It has a name on exactly two projections and is 18.2 per cent long on the one where it is famous.

paths · Paths The shortest route, and the shortest route a vehicle can fly. A leg of 60 kilometres for a vehicle whose minimum turning radius is 5, arriving on a heading 120° off the line and required to leave on one -60° off it. The straight line is the geodesic; the curve is the shortest curvature-bounded path, which is Dubins's RSR — a turn, a straight, a turn — at 67.29 kilometres against 60. The second curve is the runner-up word, drawn to show that the choice between them is a real one rather than a formality.

The shortest route a vehicle can fly

Nine rungs find the shortest path under a metric and none asks whether the thing travelling can follow it. Bound the curvature and the route depends on two headings as well as two positions: the turning cost is a fixed 1.81 kilometres whatever the leg length, so it is 18 per cent of a short leg and 0.28 per cent of a long one, and the whole of it vanishes when the vehicle happens to be pointing the right way.

paths · Paths

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Great circleGnomonicMercatorRoute planningAzimuthalBearingClosed formComposite methodConformalityConstraintGeodesicLoxodrome

All concepts