Cartographic Projection
every map is wrong, and by exactly how much
Concept

Epoch — where it appears

The date a coordinate refers to, which is part of the coordinate because the ground moves. Plate motion is centimetres a year, so a position without an epoch is ambiguous by decimetres after a decade and by metres after a working lifetime.

Named by 7 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The same coordinate on four datums. One pair of numbers — 2.0° west, 54.5° north — read as a coordinate on OSGB36, ED50, NAD27 and on WGS84, and plotted where each reading puts the mark on the ground. The spread runs to 195 metres. The numbers are identical; only what they refer to differs.

What a coordinate refers to

A latitude and a longitude are not a place. They are a claim about a model, and the model has a shape, a position, a set of marked stones and a date — change any one of the four and the ground under the numbers moves by hundreds of metres.

datums · Datum Where the ground is going, six plates. The velocity of the ground under a coordinate, computed as the cross product of each plate's rotation vector with the position, and drawn along the band where that rotation is fastest rather than over an outline this site does not hold. The quickest arrow is 75 millimetres a year on the Pacific plate, which is 1.89 metres in twenty-five years. drawn in Robinson — the arrows' directions are the projection's as much as the plates'.

The epoch is part of the coordinate

A latitude and a longitude with no date on them are incomplete, because the ground they refer to is moving at between ten and seventy millimetres a year. Australia crosses an ordinary survey tolerance in under two years and moved 1.8 metres between two versions of its own datum.

datums · Datum The same coordinate on four datums. One pair of numbers — 2.0° west, 54.5° north — read as a coordinate on OSGB36, ED50, NAD27 and on WGS84, and plotted where each reading puts the mark on the ground. The spread runs to 195 metres, and the height changes by 51, 44, 47 metres, which is the component nobody quotes.

The third coordinate moves too

A datum shift is quoted as a horizontal displacement because horizontal is what people look at. The transformation acts on a three-dimensional point, and its vertical component is between a quarter and a half of the horizontal one — 51 metres, for a British coordinate.

datums · Height A published coordinate is a definition being quoted. Re-observing a control point perfectly, with an instrument good to 20 mm, and comparing the answer to what is published for it. The published coordinate was fixed on a datum realisation that has since been superseded, which accounts for 106 m, and the ground it marks has moved 750 mm in 30 years at 25 mm a year. Both numbers are larger than the observation and neither is an error in it: subtracting a published coordinate from an observed one measures the interval between two definitions.

A published coordinate is a result

Re-observe a control mark perfectly, with an instrument good to twenty millimetres, and the answer disagrees with the published value by a hundred metres. Neither number is wrong. The difference measures the interval between two definitions.

practice · Reduction An error in a rotation rate is a longitude error that never stops growing. Where the prime meridian of each body has got to, if its published rotation rate is wrong by one unit in its last published decimal. Every line is straight through the origin, because the error is the rate error multiplied by the elapsed time and nothing else — there is no date after which it settles. Jupiter reaches 2279 metres at the equator after a century; Mars, whose rate is published to twelve decimals rather than seven, reaches 0.0011 metres over the same interval.

A longitude that drifts with the rotation rate

Ten essays here map bodies whose shape is the problem. A longitude is not about shape: it is a landmark plus an extrapolation over however many days have passed, and an error in the last published decimal of a rotation rate is a coordinate error that grows without bound in time.

datums · Bodies One velocity field, three frames. a transform boundary, drawn three times. The ground is the same ground and the arrows are not the same arrows: the fastest velocity anywhere in the 3 panels is 70.6 mm/yr and in the quietest panel the same places are nearly still. A frame is a choice of which rotation to subtract, and there is no measurement that picks one. Every panel has the same strain rate at every point.

A velocity needs a frame and a strain rate does not

One place on a plate boundary moves at 5.3, 7.0, 10.2 or 54.6 millimetres a year, and towards the south-east or the north-west, depending on which rotation was subtracted first. Every one of those readings reports the same strain rate, to two parts in a hundred thousand million.

datums · Strain How long a network has before it breaks its own tolerance. The years until the worst baseline in a 400-kilometre network exceeds five millimetres plus one part per million of its length, which is an ordinary first-order specification. A boundary zone breaks it in 16 years; a plate interior takes 1819; a rigid plate never does, at any speed, because a rigid body keeps every distance it has. Bars are clipped at five thousand years.

A grid stops fitting the ground it was laid on

A hundred-kilometre baseline across a plate boundary changes by 815 millimetres in fifty years, and the same baseline on the fastest plate in the model changes by nothing at all in the same fifty. The interval before an ordinary first-order specification is broken is six years in one place and never in the other.

datums · Strain

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

RealisationDatumPlate motionReference frameToleranceNational GridOSGB36Rigid rotationVerificationWGS84ConventionCoordinate metadata

All concepts