Theme

The thread: Computed, not quoted

Scale factors, areal ratios, angular deformations, geodesic distances and the areas of countries are all computed while the figure is drawn. None is a number recalled from a table.
10⁻⁶10⁻⁴10⁻²110010⁻¹¹10⁻⁸10⁻⁵10⁻²1010000maximum angular deformation / degreesmaximum areal errornothing here, everMercatorStereographicWeb MercatorGall–PetersMollweideEquirectangulartolerances: 0.0001° and 0.00000121 projections measured What is taught wrongly

Web Mercator is not conformal

It carries almost every map on the internet, it is named after the projection whose entire purpose is preserving angles, and it does not preserve angles. The machinery here found that without being told to look.

planeK = 0 — unrolls flatcylinderK = 0 — unrolls flatconeK = 0 — unrolls flatsphereK = 1.00torusK = 1.79pseudosphereK = -1.00K computed at each centretwo routes, one answer The impossibility

No map is faithful

Not "no map yet", and not "no map at page size". Gaussian curvature can be computed from inside a surface, a sphere has some and a plane has none, and that closes the question permanently.

a = 1.74b = 1.74an infinitesimal circle, projectedmeasured at this pointh1.7434scale along the meridiank1.7434scale along the parallela1.7434larger principal scaleb1.7434smaller principal scalea·b3.0396areal scale factorω0.00°maximum angular deformationdashed: undistorteddrawn in Mercator Measuring distortion

Tissot's indicatrix

A tiny circle on the sphere becomes an ellipse on the map, and the ellipse's two axes are the whole story. Almost every published indicatrix is drawn without them, which discards the content and keeps the decoration.

LondonTokyosolid: shortest · dashed: constant bearing+18.2% for the rhumbdrawn in Mercator Paths and directions

The shortest route is not straight

The shortest path between two points on a sphere is an arc of a great circle, and on almost every map it is a curve. The straight line on a Mercator chart is a different route entirely, and on some journeys it is twenty-eight per cent longer.

New YorkMadridsolid: shortest · dashed: constant bearing+3.0% for the rhumbdrawn in Mercator Paths and directions

Why Mercator exists

A ship can hold a compass bearing and cannot easily hold a great circle. Mercator is the answer to one question — what must a map do so that a constant bearing is a straight line — and it answers it exactly.

equator23°45°60°70°MercatorEquirectangularMillerGall–Peterslatitude of the cell1× means treated fairlyrelative to the equator What is taught wrongly

Mercator against Peters

The most-argued question in cartography, conducted almost entirely without anyone measuring anything. Both projections are exactly what they claim, each destroys what the other keeps, and the numbers are computable in either direction.

wrappedunrolled — every distance unchangedK = 0 on bothcircumference 2π = width 2π The impossibility

What can be unrolled

A cylinder is obviously curved and is intrinsically flat, so it lays out on a table with nothing stretched. A sphere is not. The distinction is exactly zero Gaussian curvature, and it is why paper tubes exist and paper globes do not.

a = 1.08b = 0.92an infinitesimal circle, projectedmeasured at this pointh1.0834scale along the meridiank0.9231scale along the parallela1.0834larger principal scaleb0.9231smaller principal scalea·b1.0000areal scale factorω9.16°maximum angular deformationdashed: undistorteddrawn in Gall–Peters Measuring distortion

What survives a change of coordinates

The scale along the meridian is a property of the map and the grid together. The principal scale factors are a property of the map alone. Only the second kind describes the projection, and the two are routinely quoted as though they were the same thing.

20°40°60°80°exact at equatorexact at 30°exact at 45°latitudeangular deformationall three are equal-area The families

What a standard parallel buys

A standard parallel is a line where the projection is exact. Choosing one does not reduce the distortion — it decides where the distortion is zero and lets everything grow away from it.

20°40°60°80°MercatorGall–PetersMollweideWinkellatitudeangular deformationalong a meridian Measuring distortion

The two ways a map is wrong

Angles and areas fail independently. A projection can be perfect about one and catastrophic about the other, and a single number summarising "how distorted" a map is has already thrown away the distinction that matters.

Mercatorgreat circle bows 3.7e-1Gnomonicgreat circle bows not at allEquirectangulargreat circle bows 2.0e-1Orthographicgreat circle bows 9.0e-2solid: shortest · dashed: constant bearingone pair of routes Paths and directions

The gnomonic companion

One projection turns every great circle into a straight line, and it is the only one that does. It shows less than half the sphere, distorts enormously, and was indispensable for three centuries because of that single exact property.

RobinsonWinkel tripelMollweideMercatorGall–PetersEckert IVsame sphere, same graticuleno two agree What each projection optimises

Compromise projections

A projection that preserves nothing exactly can distort everything less than one that preserves something exactly. For a general-purpose world map that is the right trade, and it is why the two most widely used ones today have no exact property at all.

Orthographicgreat circle bows 9.0e-2Gnomonicgreat circle bows not at allStereographicgreat circle bows 9.3e-2Azimuthal equidistantgreat circle bows 1.5e-1solid: shortest · dashed: constant bearingone pair of routes The families

The aspect is a free choice

A projection's distortion pattern is fixed relative to its own axis, and where that axis points is entirely up to the cartographer. Rotating it is the cheapest available improvement and it is the one most often left unmade.

10⁻⁶10⁻⁴10⁻²110010⁻¹¹10⁻⁸10⁻⁵10⁻²1010000maximum angular deformation / degreesmaximum areal errornothing here, everMercatorStereographicWeb MercatorGall–PetersMollweideEquirectangulartolerances: 0.0001° and 0.00000121 projections measured Measuring distortion

Measuring instead of naming

A projection is called conformal because that is its name. Running the definition as a computation over several hundred points takes about twenty lines, catches a projection the whole internet uses, and is almost never done.

All themes