Cartographic Projection
every map is wrong, and by exactly how much
Concept

Oblique — where it appears

An aspect in which a projection's axis is neither along the body's axis nor perpendicular to it. It is the general case and the two familiar ones are its special values, and fitting it to a region is what turns a projection into a design.

Named by 5 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

London to Tokyo, seen four ways. The same two routes on four projections. The gnomonic projection renders every great circle as an exactly straight line, which is what it is for; Mercator renders every rhumb line straight instead. Neither path changed — only the map did.

The aspect is a free choice

A projection's distortion pattern is fixed relative to its own axis, and where that axis points is entirely up to the cartographer. Rotating it is the cheapest available improvement and it is the one most often left unmade.

families · Families The least distortion possible over a 30° region. Scale factor along a radius of the cap, each projection normalised to unit scale at the centre. Chebyshev's criterion names the projection whose scale is constant on the boundary as the conformal map of least scale variation, and for a cap that is the stereographic projection centred on it — reaching exactly sec²(ρ/2) = 1.0718 at the rim, marked. Every other conformal projection drawn here rises past that line before it gets there. This is the only figure on the site showing an optimum rather than a comparison.

Chebyshev's criterion

The only optimality theorem in the subject. Among all conformal projections of a region, the one with least scale variation is the one whose scale factor is constant on the boundary — a criterion with a proof, a unique answer, and a test the site can run.

choosing · Choosing Mercator swung through every tilt, over Chile and the tropics. The regional distortion of one projection as its axis is tilted from the normal aspect at 0° to the transverse at 90°, each curve divided by its own value in the normal aspect so the two regions can share an axis. Chile is best at a tilt of 90°, a factor of 183.5 better than north-up; the tropics is best at a tilt of 0°, which is north-up. Rotating the sphere costs nothing and changes none of the projection's own properties, which makes this the cheapest improvement available and the one most often left unmade.

Fitting the aspect to the region

Choosing a projection is a choice among a few dozen named things. Choosing its aspect is a choice among a continuum, it costs nothing, it changes none of the projection's own properties, and for a long thin country it is worth a factor of 183.

choosing · Choosing The scale along the Madrid–Tokyo corridor. The scale factor of four projections along the great circle from Madrid to Tokyo, each normalised to its own average over the route so the comparison is of variation rather than of size. The oblique Mercator whose own equator is laid along the corridor holds the scale to 0 parts per million; Mercator varies by 118.7% over the same line. A corridor is a curve, not a region, and the projection an area criterion picks is not the one a curve wants.

Choosing for a line, not a region

Every criterion in this subject integrates over an area. A pipeline, a railway or a coastal survey is a curve, and the projection an area criterion picks for it is not the one it should have — measurably, by a factor of five thousand.

choosing · Choosing Every aspect of Mercator over Japan, and the line the old sweep searched. The regional distortion of Mercator over Japan for every position of the projection's pole — darker is better — with the meridian the site's one-dimensional sweep searches drawn on it. The sweep's best is a gain of 24.4× over the normal aspect; the two-parameter search finds 61.4×, which is 2.51 times better again, at a pole 45° of longitude away from anything the sweep could reach. The shortfall recorded when the sweep was written said this would happen for a region whose long axis runs diagonally, and this is the measurement of it.

The aspect has three numbers, not one

The site's aspect search has swung the projection's axis through one plane for a long time, and recorded that a region whose long axis runs diagonally has its optimum somewhere that plane never reaches. Searching the whole sphere of pole positions finds 2.6 times more improvement over Japan and 3.4 over the conterminous United States.

choosing · Choosing

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

AspectMercatorProjection selectionRegional distortionKavrayskiy's criterionLaborde's projectionNational GridObjective functionOblique mercatorOptimisationRotationScale factor

All concepts