Cartographic Projection
every map is wrong, and by exactly how much
Concept

ED50 — where it appears

The European Datum of 1950, a regional datum on the International 1924 ellipsoid, still carried by older mapping across much of Europe. Its shift from WGS84 is about a hundred metres and is very nearly a pure translation, which is why a similarity fit absorbs it almost exactly.

Named by 3 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The same coordinate on four datums. One pair of numbers — 2.0° west, 54.5° north — read as a coordinate on OSGB36, ED50, NAD27 and on WGS84, and plotted where each reading puts the mark on the ground. The spread runs to 195 metres. The numbers are identical; only what they refer to differs.

What a coordinate refers to

A latitude and a longitude are not a place. They are a claim about a model, and the model has a shape, a position, a set of marked stones and a date — change any one of the four and the ground under the numbers moves by hundreds of metres.

datums · Datum OSGB36 to WGS84, one parameter at a time. Each bar is how far the mark at 2.0° west, 54.5° north moves under one of the seven parameters with the other six set to zero. seven of the seven are not zero for OSGB36. The units hide the comparison: one arcsecond of rotation moves this point 30.8 metres and one part per million of scale moves it 6.36 metres, so OSGB36's scale term contributes 130 metres — more than one of its three translations.

The seven parameters, and what each one does

A datum transformation is published as three metres, three arcseconds and one part per million, in three different units — which hides the fact that all seven are the same size of thing. Converted to ground displacement, the scale term beats two of the translations.

datums · Datum What changing the datum alone does to a coordinate. The distance on the ground between a point as read on its national datum and the same numbers read on WGS84, computed through the published seven-parameter transformation. The shifts run from 49 to 166 metres. For comparison, the scale error a UTM zone introduces at its edge is under a metre per kilometre — so the datum, which is usually left unstated, dominates the projection, which is usually argued about.

Datum shifts dwarf projection errors

The projection argument is conducted in parts per million and the datum question is answered in hundreds of metres. A coordinate whose datum is unstated is out by more than any projection choice could ever put it, and almost nobody checks.

wrong · Ellipsoid

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

DatumEllipsoidHelmert transformationOSGB36RealisationWGS84Coordinate metadataCoordinate semanticsEpochFlatteningGeodetic datumInverse problem

All concepts