Theme

The thread: Measured, not named — page 13

A projection is usually called conformal because that is its name. Here it is called conformal only after the angular deformation has been computed at several hundred points and found to be zero. Essays 289 to 292 of 292.

What a reprojection does, drawn where it does it. The angular deformation of the map that takes Sinusoidal's page to Gall–Peters's — which is what a reprojection is — shaded over the sphere and drawn on Mollweide so that equal ground areas are equal page areas. Both parents are equal-area, so the composite preserves area exactly; its mean angular deformation is 55.5° against 38.9° and 32.2° for the two maps separately. Composing two maps did not average their shape errors; it made a larger one.

Measuring distortion

Two indicatrices do not make a third

Reprojecting is composing, and the composite's indicatrix is not a function of its parents'. Mollweide followed by Hammer is gentler than either map over eighty per cent of the sphere; the sinusoidal followed by Gall–Peters is worse than both everywhere. What separates them is one angle, and it is the number rung ten showed the ellipse does not carry.

Six regions, before and after. Six circular regions of unequal size on the equal-area rectangle, and the same six after the cartogram of four cities has been solved. Each drawn area is exactly its base area times the density it was asked for. The four that grow stay recognisably round; the two that shrink are drawn out into shapes that no longer resemble what they were, and nothing in the construction chose to treat them differently.

Measuring distortion

A cartogram keeps the shapes it inflates

Seven rungs build cartograms and none reads one back. Reading means recognising a region and dividing its drawn area by its base area, and the construction is against the reader twice: the correlation between how much a region grows and how much of its shape it keeps is −0.996, and the base area a reader has to divide by is the map the cartogram replaced.

One current, two maps, and only one of them conserves it. A flow that has no sources or sinks anywhere on the sphere — it is the perpendicular of a stream function's gradient, so its divergence is zero by construction — drawn on two projections. The arrows on the right are the images of the same ground velocities as the ones on the left. On the equal-area map the drawn field is still divergence-free; on the other it is not, and the arrows drawn in the warning colour are where a reader measuring the picture would find a source or a sink that is not there.

Measuring distortion

A current drawn on a page has sources

Seven rungs project a scalar field and ask what the page does to its gradient. A wind or a current is the other half of what gets mapped, and the operator that matters for it is the divergence — which is preserved by an equal-area map exactly, by no other map at all, and by a conformal map least of anybody's expectation.

Two places, one written coordinate. The lattice a coordinate written to 5 decimal places lives on, at 45° of latitude, where a cell is 1.11 metres north to south. Two real places a fifth of a cell apart are drawn as open marks and the single value they both round to as a filled one. The distance between them, computed from what was written, is exactly zero — an error a noise model cannot produce, since independent noise never puts two different points in the same place.

Measuring distortion

Rounding is not noise

Eight rungs treat a coordinate's error as noise that averages down. A published coordinate has a second error that does not: it is deterministic, it is shared between every point in the same cell, and at five centimetres apart ninety-three per cent of pairs come out as the same place — which no amount of independent noise can produce.

All threads