Cartographic Projection
every map is wrong, and by exactly how much
Figure

The arc-to-chord correction on 0.6° lines at 52° north

Drawn here at the parameters it defaults to, with every essay that calls it.
The arc-to-chord correction on 0.6° lines at 52° north. six lines of the same length and bearing, placed at different distances from the central meridian, with the angle between the projected geodesic and its chord plotted for each. The correction reaches 28.9″ at the edge of the zone and changes sign across the middle, which is what makes it geometry rather than a fudge factor. The hollow marks are the classical closed form, which agrees to 0.016″.

six lines of the same length and bearing, placed at different distances from the central meridian, with the angle between the projected geodesic and its chord plotted for each. The correction reaches 28.9″ at the edge of the zone and changes sign across the middle, which is what makes it geometry rather than a fudge factor. The hollow marks are the classical closed form, which agrees to 0.016″.

It is one of 13 figures drawn by the same construction, and the drawing above is this one with nothing changed.

4 essays call it. Every call below passes it something, because a placement that passes nothing draws whichever member of the family the generator happens to default to rather than the one its essay argues about.

Where it is called

Changing this changes every one of these figures.

The sixty zones, each six degrees wide. Every zone is a separate transverse Mercator projection about its own central meridian, so the world is covered by sixty maps rather than one. Zone 31 is picked out, running from 0° to 6° with its axis on 3°. Coordinates do not carry across a zone boundary — a point on either side of one has two entirely different eastings, and nothing in the numbers says which zone they belong to. The families

UTM and the zone system

Sixty separate maps of the world, each six degrees wide, each with a scale factor of 0.9996 chosen so the projection is wrong everywhere and less wrong at the edges. Every constant in the definition is a measured trade rather than a convention.

 What changing the datum alone does to a coordinate. The distance on the ground between a point as read on its national datum and the same numbers read on WGS84, computed through the published seven-parameter transformation. The shifts run from 49 to 166 metres. For comparison, the scale error a UTM zone introduces at its edge is under a metre per kilometre — so the datum, which is usually left unstated, dominates the projection, which is usually argued about. What is taught wrongly

Datum shifts dwarf projection errors

The projection argument is conducted in parts per million and the datum question is answered in hundreds of metres. A coordinate whose datum is unstated is out by more than any projection choice could ever put it, and almost nobody checks.

 Grid north against true north at 52°, across a 6° zone. seven meridians drawn in the grid's own coordinates. The grid's north is straight up the page everywhere by construction; the meridians are not, and the angle between them is the convergence. It is exactly zero on the central meridian, reaches 2.36° — 142 minutes of arc — at 3° out, and changes sign across the middle. The manual's γ = Δλ sin φ is 3.0″ short of it at the zone edge. The families

Grid north is not north

A grid has one north, parallel everywhere on the sheet by construction. The Earth has a different one at every point. The angle between them reaches two degrees at the edge of a UTM zone, and a straight line on the grid is not a straight line on the ground either.

 The order the corrections go in, and what it costs. Setting out a 51.8 km line on the UTM zone 31N means turning a grid bearing into an azimuth to observe, and there are two corrections: the meridian convergence, 0.8669° here, and the arc-to-chord correction, 6.242″. Each bar carries the lateral offset it produces at the far end of the line, because a bearing error is a number nobody can picture and a sideways miss is the thing that misses. The exact arc-to-chord and the classical formula every manual gives differ by 0.0044″, which is 1.10 mm at the far end — small, real, and the reason the corrections have an order rather than a sum. Grids, and what a survey does

Setting out runs the chain backwards

Turning a design coordinate into something to observe on the ground means undoing the reduction chain, and undoing a chain reverses the order as well as the operations. Two of the corrections do not commute, and getting them the wrong way round misses by a millimetre at fifty kilometres.

The whole library